Reviews for The Judge's Mansion: 8BR Historic Home in Olde Town East

We were in town for a wedding and this home was perfect because each room had privacy and their own kitchens or kitchenettes. There were also a few gathering rooms and sitting out on the porch was lovely.

A wonderful stay in a beautifully appointed set of suites! We had a blast!

Great stay, beautiful inside and was able to fit our large group very comfortably.

We needed a place for 10 of us to stay and this mansion was perfect. We each had our own bathroom and private suite which made the whole weekend so much more enjoyable. The mansion was beautiful and we enjoyed exploring the uniqueness of each room. We didn’t have any issues with parking, off street and on street.The only warning that we will make is that room #1 does not have enough standing room for anyone over 5 ft to be a shower so whoever stays in that room with either want to take a bath or use a different shower. Derek was really communicative before our stay when we had questions and ahead of check-in.I’m local to Columbus so I understood that OTE is a great area but can easily go into not great areas. So always be cautious with leaving belongings in your car but we did not have any concerns with staying there. It was easily accessible to everywhere we needed to be downtown and was a very quiet street.Overall, the Judge’s Mansion made it an incredible weekend for us and we would recommend it for large groups!

There were 16 friends from all over the country in our group in Columbus for a wedding. We rented the entire mansion. The house is as described in the listing. It’s old. It has quirks and along with that it has CHARM to spare! We were concerned that there would not be a centralized gathering place for all of us to be together but to the contrary there were so many options. We ended up congregating in the living room of suite #3 (the chamber). It is centrally located and has a nice sized kitchen and living room with a separated bedroom. Th Chamber was definitely our favorite suite in the house. The management was extremely responsive and helpful. They were able to accommodate an early check in and even brought us extra towels in a pinch. They were there within an hour of the request! The place has nice amenities as well, with all kinds of complimentary snacks and supplies. The neighborhood is hit-and-miss. There is a beautiful park and the East Market within walking distance but there are some run-down buildings as well. That did not bother us but I could see how some people may be turned off by it. The proximity to most Columbus destinations is also pretty great. I would highly recommend The Judge’s Manson to anyone, especially a large group. It was the perfect place for us!

Judge's Mansion is a unique Columbus gem. Perfect for larger groups, with historic charm and amenities to fit all your needs. I would definitely recommend staying here - the photos drew me in, and the host will ensure return booking. Thanks for a great week taking care of our leadership team!

We stayed at the Judges Mansion with a group of 15 students for a Fine Arts competition at the Convention Center. They could not stop talking about the character in the home, even down to the door hinges. It suited our needs well and quickly felt like home. We made so many precious memories in that home. The street and backyard parking was convenient and easy. It was also less than 20 minutes from every place we went during our stay. But even more than the home, the owner was a pleasure to interact with. He was prompt and thorough in handling an issue we faced during our stay. Do not hesitate to book this spot, you'll be glad you did!

This was my first experience with Air BnB. After a small problem at the very beginning of the process, everything was great. Communication was almost immediate and proactive. The location was very well maintained and lived up to its billing. 10/10 for Judges Mansion and it’s management. Thank you for a wonderful experience.

Was exactly what we needed! The hosts were very responsive and helpful.