Sugar Wood opened its doors on Prince Street with exactly two menu items: "Woody," a penis-shaped waffle, and "Kitty," its anatomically inspired counterpart. Both arrive drizzled with a choice of sauces — chocolate, strawberry, peanut butter, white chocolate, caramel — and both were designed to do one thing: make a room of friends lose it at the same time. It worked well enough that the shop started pulling visitors from around the world just to get a photo with a Woody waffle in hand, and it worked well enough that Sugar Wood has now been featured twice on Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen.

What set the shop apart from the start wasn't just the shape of the food. Sugar Wood was built as a queer- and ally-founded, sex-positive space from day one, with a stated mission of destigmatizing sex and gender stereotypes rather than reinforcing them — the whole point of a penis waffle next to a vagina waffle is that neither one is the punchline on its own. That ethos extends past the counter: the shop donates a portion of its monthly revenue to LGBTQ+ organizations, including groups supporting queer youth and the legacy of transgender activism in New York.

The NYC shop is still there, but the part of the business that's exploded is the part that ships. Sugar Wood now sends its DIY dessert kits nationwide, which means a bachelorette party in Scottsdale or a birthday in the Hamptons gets the exact same naughty-waffle experience that started the whole thing in Soho, no trip to Prince Street required.

What's actually in the box

The lineup has grown well past the original two waffles. The core kit is still the Naughty Waffle Decorating Kit — Woody and Kitty waffles shipped fully assembled, ready to drizzle and decorate as a group activity rather than something pre-made and passive. Alongside it sits the Naughty Cookie Decorating Kit, which trades waffles for a spread of cheeky shapes: Woody cookies for the classic gag, Kama Sutra cookies where guests pick a pose and decorate accordingly, and Bride Tribe cookies spelling out tributes to whoever's about to say "I do." Frosting, edible glitter, and decorations are included, so the box functions less like dessert and more like a built-in party activity — something to gather around at the kitchen table rather than just eat.

Dietary needs are covered, too. Sugar Wood accommodates dairy-free, gluten-free, nut-free, vegan, and vegetarian requests, which matters more than it sounds like for a group order where someone always has a restriction.

Why the reviews keep saying the same thing

Search through Sugar Wood's ratings and a pattern emerges fast: people expect a novelty gift and leave surprised by the actual food quality. One bachelorette-party reviewer put it plainly — the ingredients are high quality enough that the joke isn't the whole draw. Another described the waffles as delicious even after a multi-day shipping trip, which had made her nervous going in. A birthday-party customer called the whole thing "10/10 across the board" after ordering the cinnamon-vanilla waffles for her own celebration. Across nearly 2,000 ratings, the average sits at 4.9 stars, and the recurring theme isn't just "funny" — it's "actually good," which is the harder review to earn.

Logistics get the same praise. Sugar Wood ships via UPS with delivery-date selection built into checkout, so a box lands exactly when a party needs it rather than sitting in a mailroom for days. Every order is made fresh rather than pulled from inventory, and it's packed to stay good for up to a week after arrival — useful for parties where the exact schedule shifts at the last minute.

Bringing it to your own party

Kits start at $49 per party for the waffles and $45 for the cookies, and both are built to scale with group size — no guesswork on how many Woodys a bachelorette weekend actually requires. Whether the plan is a bridal shower, a milestone birthday, or just a group of friends who want dessert to double as the night's activity, Sugar Wood packs the same energy that made Prince Street a destination into a box that ships anywhere in the country.

👉 Book Sugar Wood on Batch

‍