Start with the St. Augustine Sunset Waterways Cruise, the shorter and more scenic-forward of the two at 90 minutes aboard the Exodus. This one leans into the city's history — you'll pass the St. Augustine Lighthouse, glide under the Bridge of Lions, and catch Castillo de San Marcos as the light starts to shift. It opens relaxed, almost like a sightseeing tour, then eases into music and dancing as the sky turns over and the city lights come up. It's the pick for a group that wants the postcard moment first and the party second, or for a crew where half the group wants a calm ride and the other half wants to end the night moving.

‍

The Palm Valley Sunset Cruise flips that ratio. At two full hours, it pushes further out into the protected waters near Guana Preserve, where the scenery goes full Old Florida — wide-open skies, marsh grass, the kind of quiet that makes dolphin sightings feel like a genuine event rather than background noise. The extra time changes the shape of the trip entirely: it starts as a slow, nature-forward float and only turns social on the return leg, when group games and dancing take over. If your group's idea of a great cruise involves fewer landmarks and more room to just exist on the water together, this is the version built for that.

‍

Both routes are BYOB with onboard bar access, run on Coast Guard–inspected boats with a licensed captain and crew, and cost next to nothing to book — $34 to $35 per person, which puts a full sunset outing well under the price of a single round of drinks at most waterfront bars in town. Neither guarantees dolphins, to be fair, but both put you in the kind of water where showing up counts for something even without them.

‍

For groups who don't want to share a boat with strangers on someone else's schedule, the Private Party Cruises & Event Boat Charters option removes the route entirely and lets your group build its own. Choose the Sweet Caroline for bigger crews — covered seating, open deck space, a full onboard bar setup, room to actually spread out — or the Exodus for a tighter, faster two-hour version of the same private-charter idea. Either way, you're picking the stops: a sandbar, a waterfront restaurant, a straight loop through the Intracoastal, whatever the group actually wants that day. Charters start at $900 per party, with the price scaling based on which boat and how long you're out.

‍

And if the whole group agrees a party boat isn't really the vibe, the St. Augustine Wildlife and Nature Tour offers the same historic-waterway route as the sunset cruise but at a gentler pace, with light narration from captains who know exactly where the dolphins tend to surface. No dance floor required — just good water, good company, and the same BYOB flexibility as everything else in the fleet.

‍

Book on Batch

‍

👉 St. Augustine Sunset Waterways Cruise / Palm Valley Sunset Cruise — from $34/person

‍

👉 Private Party Cruises & Event Boat Charters — from $900/party

‍

👉 St. Augustine Wildlife and Nature Tour — from $38/person

‍